The notion of an NBA Playoff MVP has long been debated among fans and analysts alike. Following a successful review last season, we once again present our mid-postseason assessment of the most valuable players in the playoffs so far. Beyond individual accolades, there’s a strong argument for recognizing an All-NBA Playoff Team, which this five-player MVP candidate list serves to highlight.
(For the record, our All-NBA Playoff Second Team and Playoff MVP honorable mentions include Stephon Castle of the San Antonio Spurs, Anthony Edwards from the Minnesota Timberwolves, James Harden of the Cleveland Cavaliers, Chet Holmgren representing the Oklahoma City Thunder, and Karl-Anthony Towns from the New York Knicks.)
5. Cade Cunningham, Detroit Pistons
Cunningham’s playoff journey may be over, but his impact was undeniable, carrying the Pistons through two grueling seven-game series. He was the team’s primary offensive engine, consistently finding his scoring and playmaking spots across the court. At 6-foot-6 and 220 pounds, his physical advantage allowed him to muscle his way to mid-range jumpers or drive to the basket, and expertly exploit mismatches on the perimeter. Despite Detroit’s anticipated weaknesses, particularly the presence of non-shooters and a lack of secondary creation, Cunningham consistently delivered. His individual brilliance shone through, proving he’s a formidable force ready for future battles.
4. Donovan Mitchell, Cleveland Cavaliers
Donovan Mitchell has been a scoring machine this postseason, leading all players in points despite having played more games than some of his peers like Jalen Brunson and Shai Gilgeous-Alexander. Mitchell is a relentless offensive threat, always seeking opportunities to score. He ranks among the greatest shooting guards in league history, with only a select few like Michael Jordan and LeBron James averaging more points per game throughout their entire playoff careers. While a championship remains within reach, the Knicks’ 2-0 lead in the Eastern Conference Finals poses a significant challenge. Mitchell’s spectacular talent, however, carried the Cavaliers this far, showcasing his remarkable individual skill, even with some defensive vulnerabilities.
3. Jalen Brunson, New York Knicks
Jalen Brunson has been nothing short of sensational. Despite his modest height, he consistently delivers breathtaking plays, whether it’s finishing at the rim, executing a sudden pull-up jumper, or sinking a step-back three-pointer. His sustained excellence leaves observers in awe. While some have questioned whether a team can win a championship with an undersized point guard as their primary option, Brunson is actively challenging that narrative. He is the Knicks’ dynamic closer, leading the playoffs in fourth-quarter scoring with incredible efficiency, making him an electrifying presence on the court.
2. Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, Oklahoma City Thunder
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, the NBA’s two-time MVP, is a model of consistency. He adapts seamlessly to any lineup, providing whatever the game demands, whether it’s scoring or creating plays. Despite occasional criticisms regarding his foul-drawing techniques, his skill in disorienting defenders and finishing through contact is undeniable, mirroring the tactics of legendary scoring guards. He leads the postseason in both points and assists per game among players who reached the second round and has been the Clutch Player of the Year in tight situations. Emulating Michael Jordan’s dominance, he’s 7 wins away from a second consecutive Finals MVP. While the Thunder’s deep roster contributes to their success, Gilgeous-Alexander’s leadership and ability to elevate his teammates are crucial to their potential dynasty.
1. Victor Wembanyama, San Antonio Spurs
Victor Wembanyama, at just 22 years old, is a basketball phenomenon. His 7-foot-4 frame combined with an unparalleled skill set allows him to do almost anything on the court, from sinking game-tying overtime three-pointers from deep to effortlessly tipping in his own misses. His physical traits and talent are almost unfair. Despite facing intense physicality, as seen in Game 2 against Isaiah Hartenstein, Wembanyama consistently delivers impressive stat lines, including points, rebounds, and assists. He is arguably the most terrifying defensive presence in the game’s history, and his rapidly evolving offensive game solidifies his position as the best player in the world at such a young age. The Spurs’ reliance on Wembanyama is evident; their performance drastically improves with him on the court, demonstrating his unique ability to alter the ‘geometry’ of the game on both ends. He is an absolute game-changer.
